Mitchell Hamline Law Review
Publication Information
53 Mitchell Hamline Law Review 136 (2026)
Abstract
The second Trump administration has engaged in the most expansive impoundments in American history. Immediately upon taking office in 2025, the President directed agencies to freeze billions in mandatory appropriations. The administration’s refusal to faithfully execute the law disrupted several government programs and the entities that rely on those funds to perform work for the American people. Lawsuits quickly challenged these impoundments. Courts have hastily ruled on challenges to the funding freezes. Everyone, it seems, has been in a hurry.
Lost in this shuffle has been an ancient writ, seemingly forgotten in its old age. The writ of mandamus, once the domain of English kings, persists in American law as a remedy that compels the performance of an official duty. Mandamus was the remedy granted in two seminal cases on withheld funds: Kendall v. United States ex rel. Stokes and Train v. City of New York. These cases demonstrate that mandamus is a vital and effective check on the executive branch’s unconstitutional rescission of funds Congress has said it must spend. Yet parties, courts, and commentators have largely overlooked the leading role mandamus has played in prior impoundment controversies. This Article seeks to fill the void by detailing the arguments in and holdings of those cases and advocating for a return to the writ as an old monarchical tool to prevent new monarchical power.
Recommended Citation
Figueroa, Joseph A.
(2026)
"The Forgotten Remedy of Faithful Execution: Kendall, Train, and Mandamus,"
Mitchell Hamline Law Review: Vol. 53:
Iss.
1, Article 7.
Available at:
https://open.mitchellhamline.edu/mhlr/vol53/iss1/7
Included in
Common Law Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Law and Politics Commons, President/Executive Department Commons